It’s been 21 years since physicist Alan Sokal submitted a bogus paper to a special “Science Wars” issue of the cultural studies journal Social Text. His paper, “Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity“, maintained that quantum gravity was a social construct, using many bizarre quotes from postmodern scholars to make its case. Almost immediately after the paper was published, Sokal revealed it was a hoax in an article in Lingua Franca.
The “Sokal Affair” inspired a lot of debate, as well as accusations that Sokal himself was unethical in submitting the paper, but I thought it made its point superbly: much of the social sciences and “culture studies” in academia is intellectually vacuous—a repository for dumb ideas couched in bad prose.
Now we have another hoax: a piece on the “conceptual penis” published in the journal Cogent Social Sciences, self described as “a multidisciplinary open access journal…
View original post 1,523 more words
Sokal Affair 2.0: Penis Envy: Addressing Its Critics https://areomagazine.com/2017/05/21/sokal-affair-2-0-penis-envy-addressing-its-critics/ via @areomagazine
LikeLike
Here is Richard Dawkins’ famous review of Sokal’s book, which was published in the Nature journal. http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~dq209/others/postmodernism.pdf
LikeLike